"It’s time — probably past time — for any of you who still think of Jayleigh Ann & The Lost Boys as “pretty good for kids” to start thinking of them as just plain good. The novelty of their whole schoolkid-prodigy thing is no longer the draw. They’ve been playing gigs around here for nearly three years, and that experience has helped shape them into a reliably entertaining, wholly professional act. The next step, one they’ve already begun to take, is shifting from largely covering other people’s songs to mostly doing their own"
— Scene Magazine